I do not like failure. It is not in my nature to quit. Yet I have had to accept failure multiple times over the past months.
With what, you ask?
Potty Training.
I'm pretty sure those words have now been added to my list of foul language. From now on when I am really mad, instead of letting a less-than-appropriate word slip I will just consciously yell "potty training!"
Having 3 independently motivated potty-trainers who trained in a single day at the age of 2 in the past set me up with unfair expectations. I knew Jacob would take longer than the others. I didn't even think twice about keeping him in diapers past his 3rd birthday. But I foolishly thought that with more time he would still have the light-bulb moment like his brother and sisters did at their second birthdays. And maybe Jacob still will. I just thought it would be before age 3 and 1/2. Or 4.
Back in October Jacob showed an interest in the potty. He was happy to sit and even had some success with wetting in his little potty. So I experimented with underwear and thought maybe he was ready. By the end of the first day he was a complete mess. The sensory experience of underwear was disturbing to him. By nap time he was anxious and unsettled. By bed time he was a wreck. I immediately changed gears and put him back in his diaper but let him use the potty if he asked. He was still having 5-6 bowel movements a day so I knew he just wasn't ready physically even though his curiosity was showing. He quickly lost interest and stopped asking to go.
The one-day attempt in October.
In December I revisited the potty effort when Jacob started expressing interest again. This time I avoided underwear and just tried making potty visits routine. "Jacob it's bath time, lets sit on the potty!" But my hard-headed little monkey quickly realized what I was tricking him into and began to resist. Rather than making a big deal out of it I let it go. I wasn't that set on potty training during the holidays anyway and we had a trip out of state coming up.
After our trip to Utah between Christmas and New Years I noticed changes in Jacob. He was sleeping better. His self stimulation behaviors started to disappear. His body seemed to be regulating and we were no longer changing 6 messy diapers a day. He was stopping play to "take care of business" and talking about family pets and family members taking potty breaks (I will spare you his descriptions).
I saw my chance. The lightbulb was flickering! There was just one more thing I could see in the way: Jacob had never, not once, indicated to Brad or I that he wanted a diaper change. We assumed this was because of 13 months in an institution where diapers are simply not changed by need, but by caregiver availability. He had learned to tune out the discomfort of a messy diaper. We believed he no longer recognized when his diaper was dirty.
So, I conducted a little experiment. I told Jacob he could have a sticker every time he told me he needed a diaper change. I took him to the store and he picked smiley face stickers. And for 3 days he told me every time he had a messy diaper.
Ah-ha! He did know!
It was finally time. The game was on. I was ready. I did everything just like I had with Caity, Amber and Drew: I got M&Ms to reward dry and clean pants, I had special drinks on hand, I got new character underwear to replace the generic training pants I had used in October, I talked it up to Jacob all week and even took him to the store to pick out a special prize (for that very first poop on the potty). He was so excited and so was I.
The first day was a great success. No major sensory issues about the underwear like in October. A few minor accidents mostly around the illusive "Number 2" duty. But numerous successes with staying dry.
Day two Jacob was nervous. He knew he needed to take care of his bowel movement in the potty rather than his underwear. He really wanted to open that truck he picked at the store. But he was scared. And so my child who up until February of this year has pooped 4-6 times a day suddenly did not have a BM all day. Too much information? I'm sorry, this is a story about potty training.
Day three we crashed and burned. Nothing makes me crazier than number two accidents in underwear. And Jacob had thrown in the towel. Accidents were the norm. He would still go pee if I took him but he had stopped asking to go.
I resolved to persist. I had quit twice already. Not this time. I have a stronger will than you, little 3-year-old.
Sigh.
Two weeks later I was loosing my sanity. And Jacob was no more interested in going in the potty than he had been in October and December. My frustration was effecting my parenting ability. And Jacob was crying, hitting, squirming, and floping every time I told him it was "time to check for dry pants for a candy". He started telling me, "I cared" (scared) every time he needed to have a BM. I tried letting him wear a diaper while sitting on the potty to go poop (a sensory trick). We even tried standing in a diaper in the toilet room. He would not do it. He was "cared". We tried using pull ups instead of underwear to make accidents less stressful for both mom and Jacob. We tried getting daddy and siblings involved. I felt like we had tried everything.
Finally, I had the moment of clarity: why does this need to happen right now? Was this my agenda and time frame or his little body really being ready and just a matter of will? He had shown some of the signs of readiness, but would it really be the end of the world if I gave him more time to mature? There are still many areas that Jacob is a good 8-12 months behind his peers in development. Would I feel as anxious about his potty training if he were 2 and 1/2 instead of 3 and 1/2?
Jacob will not go to Kindergarten in diapers. There is nothing pressing us to potty train this moment (like a preschool that requires children to be potty trained). We have time. And it is okay to give him time.
So, he's back in diapers. Failure? Maybe not.